Philly Schools Give Condoms to 14-Year-Olds

by Nathan Harden - Fix Editor on December 24, 2012

Students as young as 14 in Philadelphia will soon have access to unlimited free condoms, courtesy of the city government. And while parents will be able to “opt-out” by sending a letter to their child’s school, administrators have made it clear that they will not monitor or restrict access to the condoms, even for those students whose parents have signed “opt-out” letters.

In other words, if your child attends high school in Philadelphia, then the government has taken control of your 14-year-old’s access to birth control, and there’s nothing you can do about it.

The Philadelphia Inquirer reports that 22 city high schools will receive large, clear plastic condoms dispensers over the holiday break. The dispensers will be mounted to the wall just inside doorway to the administrative offices of the schools.

The 22 schools targeted for the program reported the highest rates of sexually transmitted diseases among students. Free condoms are already available in some Philadelphia schools, and in since April 2011, the city has given away about four million condoms, according to the Inquirer.

That’s four million condoms in just over eighteen months.

Despite this veritable sea of latex, the city’s deputy mayor for health and opportunity, Donald F. Schwarz, told reporters that there is “an epidemic of sexually transmitted disease in adolescents in Philadelphia.” And that one in four new HIV infections in the city are in teens.

When asked more specifically about how schools would respect the wishes of parents who didn’t want their children to have access to birth control without their knowledge, Assistant Superintendent Dennis W. Creedon made it clear to the Inquirer that the schools would do absolutely–nothing. “Students are to honor the wishes of their parents. If a student disrespects their guardian’s directive, that is an issue of the home,” he said.

Here at The College Fix, we think that if schools are going to ignore a “guardian’s directive,” even after guardians submit it to schools in writing, then it isn’t simply an issue of the home; rather, it is most definitely an issue of governmental abuse of power. Why can’t schools that choose to distribute condoms to do so in a way that respects parental consent?

We don’t think government bureaucrats should be giving birth control to 14-year-olds in direct defiance of parental consent. Philadelphia officials are effectively saying, “Go to hell,” to any parent who insists on being involved in his or her 14-year-old child’s health choices. And we find this dismissive attitude towards the rights of parents deeply troubling.

Click here to Like The College Fix on Facebook.

Image source:  RoRi630 / Wikimedia Commons

  • http://www.facebook.com/bpuharic Bob Puharic

    Maybe they should follow conservative advice and give them guns. After all, condoms are harmful and guns aren’t, according to right wing myth

  • TomHandley

    Aren’t there more important things we should be worrying about? Give me a break! I realize that the government handing out condoms doesn’t jive with conservative principles in a perfect ideal world, but come on, this issue is far too petty to be some front-page writeup, unless this is supposed to be a publication only for born-again Christians. When we get all up in arms and propel these barely relevant social issues into the spotlight, we alienate younger voters and appear to be an out of touch party of old white men who want to control everyone’s sex lives. Considering the numerous and unending assaults on freedom and limited government that are very real and dangerously close to destroying our way of life, why don’t we cut out the social conservative B.S. and try to unify as many people as possible in our fight against the big government nanny state that the communist left wants to impose on us.

    These are the types of things that communities can deal with- I have no problem with social conservatism, and greatly sympathize with the sentiments of social conservatives. But let’s keep it out of state and national politics. There are far, far more important challenges to deal with, and we face extremely dire consequences if we cannot counter the influence of the left wing socialist agenda. The left’s rising influence is bad news for us all, and if we don’t stop alienating young people and dividing ourselves from within, we will reach a tipping point where it will be too late (see: Europe). It does not do any good for our cause, or anything, or anyone, to get all worked up and publish some feature article about an outrage over condoms. Who the hell cares? Let’s sort out pissant debates over condom use in local politics and focus on any of the thousands of vastly more important problems otherwise.

  • ML

    I see no problem here. Obviously, some of these students were having sex; or do you believe the sexually transmitted diseases are the result of some kind of divine intervention (maybe that will be how the devil’s son will arrive on earth)? The school district recognized that students tend to have trouble learning when they have active syphilis infections or have just developed HIV, and so it provided a simple, inexpensive, and quite effective (though not foolproof) remedy as a completely optional resource for those who wish to use it. There is, in fact, no evidence that students with access to condoms are more likely to have sex or to have sex earlier. The only result (besides a few who use them as balloons) is that fewer students develop truly serious infections that can stay with them for life and fewer become pregnant, especially when the condoms are coupled with quality sex education.

    Schools provide a lot of things to students, even when parents might have different views on whether their children should have access to them. Some parents might object to grilled cheese sandwiches in the cafeteria, while others might not want their offspring to consume any meat. Some parents don’t mind if their daughter holds hands at lunch with a significant other, while others would find the idea abhorrant. A devoutly religious parent may feel just as strongly about their children having access to beef, pork, cheeseburgers, long pants, women with uncovered hair, classmates of the opposite sex, or the internet as some parents feel about their children having access to birth control. They are entitled to those beliefs and to run their family as they choose, but cannot expect schools to police access to all potentially objectionable items and knowledge.

    I ask what kind of system any concerned parents (and this editorial doesn’t actually cite any parents who have a problem with the policy) would prefer? Should students have to visit a school secretary, complete a Condom Request Form in triplicate, have their identity cross-checked against a list of students who have been forbidden condoms? Is it possible that such a system might deter students from using lifesaving birth control even when their parents have no objections? Should overcrowded and underfunded public schools devote staff time to distributing condoms according to parents’ wishes?

    Or should those students who are already looking to have sex have the ready opportunity to use what is truly one of the more momentous inventions of mankind to protect themselves and their partners should they choose to become intimate? That way schools can get back to educating students instead of comforting and aiding the sick or pregnant.

  • http://twitter.com/EARWAX1000 PHILIP SCHNEIDER

    Yeah, they got it right!

    Just look at “Philly” it’s the city of the future, it’s the city of our dreams.
    The schools, the crime rate, the sexually transmitted diseases among young kids proves how “right” they are.
    DO IT! and while your at it, have real live demonstrations in the class rooms of “how to”.
    No need for bananas or cucumbers . . . . just DO IT!
    And then bring in Anderson Cooper and have some kids kiss his crotch or better yet bring in Bill Clinton . . . . and some cigars.
    AND . . . . make sure you read the statistics to the kids showing “There is, in fact, no evidence that students with access to condoms are more likely to have sex or to have sex earlier”.

  • http://www.facebook.com/joey.nicastro.77 Joey Nicastro

    Any adult who gives a 14 year old a condom should be arrested on the spot without question !!

    • katie

      ALL HAIL TEEN PREGNANCY

  • http://twitter.com/DadsHouseEdCent Dads House Ed Center

    Condoms are 100% ineffective with teen girls who want to get pregnant.
    http://www.squidoo.com/TeenBoysNSexEd

  • katie

    “LOLZ GUYS TEEN PREGNANCY FTW”

    College Fix, grow up.