Colleges that rushed to institute one-sided investigation procedures for sexual impropriety must have foreseen that they would be used against administrators as well as students and faculty.
UC-Berkeley’s Graham Fleming, who resigned as vice chancellor for research last week, is now claiming the school violated his due process when it investigated him for “inappropriately touching” a former junior colleague and sending her “overly affectionate emails.”
The Daily Californian reports that Fleming called the school’s report on him “riddled with inconsistencies, mischaracterization of the facts, … distortion of witness statements, as well as the selective omission of relevant information.”
Fleming was apparently judged by the “preponderance of evidence” standard:
According to the San Francisco Chronicle, [the UC Office of the President] concluded that Fleming “more likely than not” violated the policies.
A news release from public relations consultant Sam Singer, who works with Fleming’s lawyer, said Fleming denied the charges of harassment made by [Diane] Leite and resigned under protest, saying UCOP “mishandled” charges made against him in the investigation.
“(UCOP) bungled the investigation,” Singer said. “Fleming’s legal counsel provided ample evidence that the allegations are false.”
Leite, who filed the complaint against Fleming, left the school under her own cloud:
According to Singer, Fleming was first made aware of the allegations last year, two years after Leite was fired for allegedly violating university policies after she increased the salary of one of her employees with whom she was having a sexual relationship.
Fleming called his relationship with Leite a “long-standing and affectionate friendship” that was never romantic.
Here’s something you don’t see often: a public feud between dueling groups of sexual-assault prevention activists.
The Daily Californianreports that University of California-Berkeley activists are trashing a statewide group that represents rape crisis centers.
The California Coalition Against Sexual Assault, among others, is backing a state senate bill – which has now been “postponed indefinitely” – that would define a “sexual assault counselor” as someone “employed by” a rape crisis center.
The current definition in state law says such a person can be “engaged in any office, hospital, institution, or center commonly known as a rape crisis center.”
While the coalition says the change is meant to clarify qualification requirements for counseling, UC-Berkeley activists say that’s an attack on rape victims:
Student Advocate Rishi Ahuja said that the coalition stands to gain financially from the passage of this bill and that its promotion of the bill takes away from the choices of sexual assault survivors.
“The goal of confidential and privileged advocates is for survivors to choose the least traumatic way for them to report,” Ahuja said. “What if survivors don’t feel comfortable about reporting to (rape crisis centers)?” …
ASUC Senator Haley Broder said she is concerned that the bill could compromise advocates’ confidentiality and privilege, “which would be incredibly detrimental to student survivors.”
“Militarism is not divine,” either: The point of the military-industrial complex is to “stimulate” the economy. And Muslims must be careful not to “replicate imperial structures” even as they fight against them.
So said Hatem Bazian, whose co-founding of Zaytuna College earlier this year was preceded by more than a decade of activism against Israel. The remarks were made to a group of Muslim Student Association members at UCLA on March 11, according to tweets by the group.
The association described Bazian’s message as how Islam “informs us of our responsibility to fight for social and economic justice in our societies despite the stigma of being labeled ‘political’ or ‘radical.’”
When Bazian, the chairman of American Muslims for Palestine, helped establish Students for Justice in Palestine in 2001, he helped start the movement that has successfully pushed divestment from companies that do business with the Israeli government.
He has also grown a curious coalition over the past decade: a union of socialist and Muslim religious activists. Bazian has been active as a leader in the socialist movement as well as divestment campaigns.
Just a year ago, Bazian was accused by a student of forcing his Asian American studies class – subtitled “Islamophobia” – to “tweet weekly on Islamophobia,” according to moderate Muslim activist Tarek Fatah. Bazian told Fatah that students were “asked” to post weekly about “something related to the course content.”
From his position at UC-Berkeley, Bazian has frequently led protests against Israel, most recently in September.
Video from that “International Day of Action” protest shows participants chanting mantras connected to acts of violence, including “From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be Free” – hinting at the removal of Israel as a Jewish state.
Just like the 1960s civil rights movement
While Bazian has been given a platform by the UC system for his left-wing, anti-Israel rhetoric, the school hasn’t been so friendly to its right-leaning voices.
After being dropped by UCLA for questioning the scientific basis for regulations on diesel emissions, researcher James Enstrom got a $140,000 settlement from the school and reinstatement of his research privileges earlier this month, as The College Fix reported.
Asked about his UCLA talk and the issues he discussed, Bazian sent The Fix two of his recent articles.
A group of University of California-Berkeley students known as the “Bathroom Brigade” is occupying restrooms and covering up the gender icons on the doors.
They want to force the administration to more quickly put gender-neutral restrooms in every campus building.
The Daily Californian reports that the group’s notices on restroom doors encourage “everyone, of all genders, to use this bathroom”:
Additional notices, designating the bathrooms as gender-neutral spaces, were placed over stalls, mirrors and towel dispensers, while participants handed out flyers to incoming students. …
“I think the university’s administration has dragged its feet,” said Sben Korsh, a first-year graduate student, in an email. “The campus has known about this issue for decades, and they are still throwing up bureaucratic barriers for providing these safe spaces for students.”
The school argues there’s more at stake than “safe spaces”:
According to Christine Shaff, director of communications for the campus real estate division, the process of converting gendered bathrooms can be far more complex than it initially appears. While in some instances, Shaff said, it costs as little as “changing a lock,” more commonly, conversion is a coordinated effort between architects and building officials, who must consider state building codes and the cultural and religious preferences of the many varied groups on campus.
“There’s all kinds of regulations that make changing the designation much more complicated than changing the sign on the door,” Shaff said.
Um, yeah. Here’s an instructional video on what the gender-neutral conversion of multi-stall facilities might look like.
The United States Department of Justice wants to know if what your college is doing about sexual assault is effective.
It’ll give you some cash to figure that out.
The DOJ’s National Institute of Justice, “alongside the Office on Violence Against Women and Office of Justice Programs,” has now opened the application process for researchers to obtain grants to study the issue.
The justice institute hopes to shed light on newer, more promising methods of addressing sexual assault on college campuses, the proposal said.
The program comes in response to the April 2014 White House Task Force Report to Protect Students From Sexual Assault, which advocated improved understanding of campus sexual assault investigations and adjudications on campuses.
In May of last year, the White House released a list of universities, including UC Berkeley and three other California schools, under investigation for possible violations of federal law over the handling of sexual violence and harassment complaints.
According to the proposal, applicants for the grant must be the entity with primary responsibility for conducting and leading the sexual assault research.
UC Berkeley senior Aryle Butler, a member of the survivor advocacy organization End Rape On Campus, says that “the DOJ grant is a good initiative to analyze our campus more objectively.” But, she added, if Berkeley decided to apply for a grant, “there should be an additional layer of oversight and protection to the research to ensure that statistics are not deflated or inflated.”
Students at UC Berkeley this week held a protest against a professor who recently told his class the Black Lives Matter movement “needed to stop scapegoating the cops” and shared statistics to argue black-on-black crime is the real harm facing the black community.
Saying he was inspired by the campus Black Lives Matter conversation, Professor Steven Segal, who is white, made his argument not only as part of a lecture to his social work class, but also delivered some of his comments via a rap he wrote.
The professor at UC Berkeley – the birthplace of the free speech movement – has since been accused of racism and of creating a “toxic climate for people of color in the classroom,” and a #BlackLivesMatter sit-in demonstration against the longtime scholar was held Tuesday.
“We just hosted a teach in and sit in [over] a mandatory policy class in which there was an instance of racism enacted by the professor,” said UC Berkeley student Ariana Allensworth, a campus Black Lives Matter organizer, regarding the Feb. 10 incident in the graduate-level course. “We hosted a mediation and dialogue to remedy the harm done in the class and [to discuss] how our school can end institutionalized racism.”
The video shows them hoist a sign on Haviland Hall, where Segal teaches, accusing the school of oppression while singing the so-called Michael Brown anthem “which side are you on friend, which side are you on? … We will fight for freedom, till justice is won.”
Segal had allegedly “silenced students who questioned and pushed back on his reasoning,” some students claimed in a write-up of the classroom incident on Social Work Helper. According to the narration in the video, “many left the class crying.”
Some students have accused the professor of making the classroom environment feel “unsafe.” Students too traumatized to return to Segal’s classroom have been allowed to transfer to a different class.
“A white tenured male professor had spent his class period rapping about ‘black on black crime’ a day after a school-wide discussion on black lives matter,” the video’s captioning states. “The professor had a captive audience because all first-year community mental health students were required to take his course.”
Segal has since apologized to his class, The Daily Californian student newspaper reports.
“Working with the students was very productive and I apologize for any misunderstanding,” Segal also said in an email to The Cal. “I completely respect the students and want to continue to be in dialogue with them. I know by working together we can strengthen our commitment to building the best School of Social Welfare we can.”
In a campuswide email sent the day of the incident, Jeffrey Edleson, dean of the School of Social Welfare, stated: “We understand that a faculty-student exchange in one of our classrooms today caused offense and great distress to some of our students and made the classroom environment feel unsafe. We deeply regret the reported incident.”
According to the YouTube video description, the student protestors have demanded “a strategic plan that addresses faculty incompetence in facilitating discussions about power, privilege and oppression in their classrooms … ” and that Edleson “agreed to co-develop the strategy with student organizers.”
But comments about the incident on The Daily Californianwebsite indicate many among the campus community do not have sympathy with the protestors.
“Uh, no, guys. If Segal were attempting to silence you because he didn’t agree with what you said, that would be oppression. It seems to me he was expressing an opinion. Attacking him instead of addressing how his opinion is wrong is a classically weak argument,” stated one.
Said another: “Does anyone else miss the old days when Berkeley and its students stood FOR free speech?”
The College Fix provides college students a platform to gain journalism experience under the guidance of veteran editors.
Fix Editor Jennifer Kabbany previously worked as a daily newspaper reporter and columnist for a decade, as well as held editorial positions at The Weekly Standard, Washington Times and FrontPageMagazine.
Assistant Editor Greg Piper spent years as a technology policy reporter and editor in Washington, D.C., and guest hosted on C-SPAN’s “The Communicators.”
Assistant Editor Dave Huber has blogged on education, politics and entertainment for more than a decade, including for NewsBusters.