Original. Student reported. Your daily dose of Right-minded news and commentary from across the nation
Uh oh: A ‘studies’ professor looks at superheroes

Sometimes I wonder why I didn’t continue my education … pursue a doctorate in some sort of “studies” field so I could write up a jumbled bunch of nonsense and get it printed in a specialized journal.

And y’know what? I’d do something no other “studies” prof has done: provide a “postmodernist lingo decoder” with each of my articles so laymen could translate my BS.

Unfortunately Utrecht University’s Anne Kustritz isn’t as accommodating as I would be. In the latest edition of the journal Sexualities, the assistant professor of Media and Culture Studies, whose work focuses on “creative fan communities, digital economies, transmedia business practices, queer representation, and intersectional queer and feminist theory,” compares superheroes — specifically Superman and the Flash — to the LGBT community in (and out) of the metaphorical closet.

For example, Clark Kent’s classic change to the Man of Steel in the “confined space” of a phone booth “invites association with the closet.”

In the early-2000s television series “Smallville,” did you know Clark didn’t just represent a force for good over evil? He also personified “American conservative ‘family values’ politicians who place central importance on the nuclear family, bifurcated gender roles,” not to mention the pro-life movement … whereas his kryptonite-mutated enemies represented threats “to the existing social hierarchy.” This means folks like “unpopular people running for class president,” “ugly girls who want to become pretty,” and a “a metaphorically gay man exacting revenge on his metaphorical bashers.”

In other words, “Smallville” had a “fixation with purity and the perversion of average citizens into grotesque threats to the social order fits within the earlier political-cultural structure and enforces closeting as a space of silencing and shame,” Kustritz writes.

To better, er, understand the absolute nonsense Ms. Kustritz spews forth, she also tries to claim science fiction author Larry Niven’s classic piece “Man of Steel, Woman of Kleenex” is about Superman finding “queer alternatives to normative heterosexual penetration.” The only problem is, nowhere in the work does Niven suggest any such thing. (I’m a life-long Niven and have read most of his works.)

In the same manner, the professor claims the latest television production of “The Flash,” which takes place in the more socially tolerant era of the 2010s, “imagines a post-shame version of the closet, which dramatizes practices of secrecy and hiding in the absence of stigma.”

Apparently (what other term can I use?) this means that although the situation for the queer community has “improve[d] dramatically in formal terms” over the last decade, there remains an “entrenchment of homophobic violence,” this time via social media.

“Fear of detection may no longer be organized around legal forms of oppression,” Kustritz says, “but instead around dispassionate algorithmic processes of sorting people between citizens recognized by law and the social order, and those consigned to the state of exception outside of law and society.”

Who is she kidding? If anything, this is the situation faced by contemporary conservatives and Republicans, not the (largely) liberal LBGT community. Google constantly taking sides with one side of the political aisle, for example. Conservatives suffering censorship at the hands of social media giants Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube.

Ironically, in one of the latest online scuffles, YouTube demonetized conservative Steven Crowder due to pressure from gay Vox.com writer Carlos Maza.

MORE: Prof: Superheroes should stop saving the world b/c climate change

MORE: Prof wonders why progressive politics are always held by comics’ villains

IMAGES: Twitter

Like The College Fix on Facebook / Follow us on Twitter

About the Author
Assistant Editor
Dave has been writing about education, politics, and entertainment for over a decade, including a stint at the popular media bias site Newsbusters. He is a retired educator with over 25 years of service and is a member of the National Association of Scholars. Dave holds undergraduate and graduate degrees from the University of Delaware.

Add to the Discussion