EDITORS' CORNER
LEGAL • OPINION/ANALYSIS

Cornell professor calls on county to rip tax exemption away from frat houses

Share to:
More options
Email Reddit Telegram

Professor Judith Hubbard; Cornell Duffield Engineering

OPINION: Academia decries President Trump’s education policy, but has no problem using levers of government for their own means

Cornell University’s fraternities should lose their county property tax exemption because of how the school allegedly mishandled a sexual assault complaint, so argues a professor and local politician.

Professor Judith Hubbard led the charge in the Tompkins County Legislature to reexamine property tax exemptions given to fraternities. Hubbard, an earth scientist, also is a legislator in the county. She first pushed for the reexamination in early October, soon after news broke of Jane Doe’s accusations of being raped by multiple men at a frat house.

“The Chi Phi chapter house was given to Cornell in 1973,” Hubbard said, as reported by the Cornell Daily Sun. “To keep it tax-exempt, the law requires that Cornell control the house, including who lives there. If that is true, then Cornell bears more responsibility for what happens in that building than has been widely recognized.”

Put another way, Hubbard does not like how Cornell operates, so she wants to use the levers of government to force it to change, including presumably cracking down on Greek life.

There is nothing wrong with looking at who really qualifies for property tax relief. This is especially true when wealthy institutions get breaks, leaving low-income and small businesses holding the bag to make up the lost revenue.

However, there is something wrong with hypocrisy.

Last year, Hubbard announced her candidacy for the county legislature as a way to stand up to President Donald Trump and his supposed unfair attacks on higher education.

The student newspaper reported last March: “Protecting funding for academic institutions such as Cornell is an important issue for Hubbard’s campaign, she said, especially as someone who has personally felt the effects of grant cuts.”

“A lot of people are going to be impacted by the federal attack on higher education,” Hubbard said. “There’s a lot of risk of people who are employed on grants being laid off because there’s no more money.”

Understandably, Hubbard feels the cuts are unfair. However, she should now consider how she is like Trump. As a county legislator, she is exercising her proper authority to review how the county spends money and how it taxes its citizens. Likewise, President Trump is using his proper authority to reevaluate how much money is spending on federal research grants and what the priorities of those grants are.

The property tax review decision, made in early October, also suffers from the same overreaction seen elsewhere. Remember that the school canceled a drone show tied to homecoming weekend because of accusations about something that allegedly happened two years ago.

Yet slowly, more and more information has come out calling into question how much of a victim Jane Doe really was.

As first reported by the New York Times, Doe at first was proud of herself for participating in group sexual activity, but only began to feel shame after gossip spread about the situation.

Professor Hubbard seems like someone who is genuinely concerned about justice – that should include all those accused of misconduct or crimes.