FIX EXCLUSIVES
LEGAL

Jury holds U. Maryland liable after cleared student was labeled ‘rapist,’ ousted from lacrosse team

Share to:
More options
Email Reddit Telegram

First-of-its-kind ruling reflects ‘long-standing’ issue of bias, scholar says

In a recent landmark case, a federal jury found the University of Maryland was “deliberately indifferent” to the sex-based harassment of a male student after he was cleared of sexual misconduct allegations. 

A scholar says this first-of-its-kind ruling reflects a “long-standing” issue of bias on college campuses.

The male student, who filed under the pseudonym John Doe, was one of two men accused of rape by a female peer in October 2020. After a lengthy investigation and a five-day hearing, an officer found both men not responsible, according to the ruling. 

The officer concluded that the accuser’s credibility was “significantly undermined” and that forensic testing contradicted her claims. She did not appeal the decision.

Despite Doe being cleared, accuser Jane Roe and the campus group Preventing Sexual Assault began targeting Doe. They publicly labeled him a rapist who was “under investigation,” causing him to be disinvited from social events. 

At a PSA “Real Talk” event, Roe named Doe as one of her rapists and described the alleged incident in detail. She also approached his friends to call him a rapist. One PSA member posted multiple times about him on a messaging board called Yik Yak, including a post calling him a “sexual predator.” Roe referenced him in a campus journal interview about sexual assault.

PSA also pressured the lacrosse club’s leadership to remove Doe, claiming he had raped Roe and that the Office of Civil Rights and Sexual Misconduct had mishandled the case. 

Doe filed a complaint with OCRSM, which was dismissed after winter break. Officials said there was “no evidence that [Roe] directly communicated anything to the UMD Club Lacrosse that would entail excluding you from any of its programs or activities” and that the allegations did not meet the policy definition of retaliation.

However, the harassment continued. When OCRSM informed both PSA and Club Lacrosse that they could not remove Doe based on allegations for which he was found not responsible, PSA suggested they find “a way to really just make [Doe] feel unwelcome enough that he doesn’t want to come around anyway.”

The Lacrosse Club president ultimately removed Doe from the club. He told Kurt Klier, the university’s director of club sports, that they needed to be “very careful with what we say to [PSA Defendants], as they spread information very quickly and can single handedly ruin our reputation if we don’t do what they want to see us do.”

Doe then filed a second complaint with OCRSM, to which he never received a response. He formally sued the university in April 2022.

The jury found the university liable for “deliberate indifference” under Title IX after determining that Doe was subjected to harassment on the basis of his sex and that it was severe enough to deprive him of an educational opportunity or benefit.

To prove “deliberate indifference” under Title IX, Doe had to show that he faced sex-based harassment, that the harassment was severe and pervasive enough to deny him equal access to educational opportunities, and that the university could be held responsible for it.

The jury answered yes to all questions.

While the original lawsuit sought $10 million in damages, Doe was ultimately awarded $1 in nominal damages.

Professor Jonathan Turley, who teaches at George Washington University Law School, told The College Fix that “the case raises a long-standing complaint that universities enforce speech and anti-discrimination laws in manifestly biased ways.”

“Administrators often appear unmotivated and inert when conservatives are harassed or attacked. Many with unpopular views or reputations are left to succumb to the elements by passively aggressive university officials,” he added. 

One of Doe’s attorneys, Jared Roberts, celebrated the decision in a post on X.

“Today, after a week long jury trial, and five years of litigation, a Maryland jury found the University liable for violating federal law. These are the days you don’t forget as a lawyer,” he wrote. 

Attorney Jason Greaves wrote on X that “[Doe] and his mother burst into tears” when the decision was announced. 

“It was a powerful moment, and an important result for falsely accused men everywhere,” he wrote. 

Greaves told The Daily Wire that this ruling is the first time a jury has ever found that false sexual assault accusations can be considered sex-based harassment. 

However, the university stands by its actions. 

In a statement to Diamondback News, a spokesperson said, “The University of Maryland disagrees with, but nonetheless respects, the decision of the jury, and otherwise maintains that it appropriately followed and applied Title IX regulations.”

Reached by The Fix, the Maryland Office of the Attorney General, which represented the university during the trial, declined to comment on whether it intends to challenge the ruling. UMD did not respond to a request for comment.