Original. Student reported. Your daily dose of Right-minded news and commentary from across the nation
U. Michigan paper compares plight of US Muslims to that of interned Japanese-Americans

This past Wednesday, the University of Michigan student paper featured an article which compares contemporary anti-Muslim/Muslim-American sentiment to the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II.

Colin Beresford’s piece in The Daily Michigan begins ominously enough, with President Franklin Roosevelt’s notorious Executive Order 9066 which gave the green light to the internment. The order “was met with nearly no opposition by the non-Japanese-American population,” he adds.

Fast forward to 2016 where then-presidential candidate Donald Trump discussed a possible “Muslim registry” and sought a ban on travel from several Muslim-majority countries.

“You sometimes feel as if you don’t belong because of certain policies, certain wars and especially this year with the Muslim registry. I have definitely felt as if I’ve questioned, ‘Am I really American?’” University of Michigan senior Haleemah Aqel said. “We kind of all just feel sometimes as if we don’t belong.”

Aqel, who is the campus Islamophobia Working Group student coordinator, did concede, however, that despite “experienc[ing] forms of discrimination [similar] to that of Japanese-Americans during World War II,” the severity of the discrimination is “on different levels.”

From the article:

Japanese-Americans have recognized similarities between the oppression they and generations before them faced during World War II and the oppression Arab and Muslim Americans face. The similarities in oppression have pushed Japanese-Americans to stand up for the rights of Arab and Muslim Americans.

Matthew Stiffler, a researcher at the Arab American National Museum and lecturer at the University of Michigan, noticed the alliance form in the early ’90s, long before the announcement of the immigration ban from the majority-Muslim countries.

“The Japanese and the Arab community specifically and the Japanese and the Muslim community more broadly has had an affinity not just since the announcement of the Muslim ban in January, but going back a lot further,” Stiffler said. “So the first case that I found of cooperation was in 1991. That was the run up to the first Gulf War in Iraq.”

Stiffler added the support for the Arab and Muslim American communities started with a Japanese-American congressman. …

LSA junior Maureen O’Bryan, the co-event chair for the Japanese Student Association, wrote in an email interview that connecting Japanese discrimination to the discrimination of Arab and Muslim Americans today puts their reality in context.

“It’s powerful because Japanese-Americans have (experienced) this and we say never again should this happen,” O’Bryan wrote. “I think if the Trump administration really wants to use Japanese incarceration as precedent for his Muslim ban, he’s going to see a strengthening alliance between these two groups because we’re not going to let what happened to us be used against another minority group that is a supposed ‘threat’ to national security because it was found that Japanese-Americans did not pose any threat to the U.S. during WWII.”

The US Supreme Court recently sided with the Trump administration by allowing it to keep a ban on refugees from entering the country. A lower court had ruled against the president and would have permitted the entrance of some 24,000 refugees by the end of October.

Read the full Michigan Daily piece.

MORE: Portland State paper says it fired editor who quoted Muslim for ‘ongoing breaches in trust’

MORE: Deportation, travel ban crises snub black people’s suffering, campus speaker says

IMAGE: Alex Brylov/Shutterstock

Like The College Fix on Facebook / Follow us on Twitter

Add to the Discussion