‘We view this as discriminatory treatment of Jewish and Israeli students, with serious implications under Northwestern’s civil rights obligations’
A food festival at Northwestern University is facing external criticism from an antisemitism watchdog after student organizers excluded Wildcats for Israel from its event. The decision to cancel the event altogether has led to a civil rights investigation by the university.
Spoon University canceled its Nov. 6 event, Cultural Food Fest, rather than allow Wildcats for Israel to attend. The organization, which primarily focuses on cuisine around town, cited the group’s “political” nature and also accused Israel of committing genocide.
The decision by the culinary food group is “deeply troubling” according to Michael Teplitsky, the founder and president of Coalition Against Antisemitism at Northwestern. His group filed a formal civil rights complaint with the university.
“We view this as discriminatory treatment of Jewish and Israeli students, with serious implications under Northwestern’s civil rights obligations,” Teplitsky, a double alumnus of Northwestern, told The College Fix via email last week.
He said being Israeli is not a political identity.
“Singling out Jewish and Israeli students for exclusion based on their association with Israel is deeply troubling,” Teplitsky said. “Students should not have to disavow their national or cultural identity to participate in campus life.”
He said his group appreciates the decision to freeze Spoon University’s status as an organization.
But he also wants to see a further investigation into the other clubs who pressured Spoon University to cancel the event.
“Equally concerning is the involvement of three other student organizations: 1) the Asian Pacific American Coalition (APAC), 2) Alianza, and 3) the Middle Eastern North African Student Association (MENA),” Teplitsky wrote, “whose joint public statement raises additional questions about coordinated exclusion and the standards being applied to Jewish and Israeli students.”
Teplitsky said Northwestern needs to investigate all involved, preserve communications, and “impose appropriate disciplinary consequences, including potential suspension or revocation of registered student organization status where warranted.” Officials should also “publicly reaffirm that Jewish and Israeli students have the same rights to participate in university-sponsored activities as every other student.”
He cited the school’s November 2025 agreement with the Department of Justice to pay $75 million and address antisemitism claims.
Teplitsky also said he does not believe Spoon University has a freedom of association claim, when asked by The Fix about this possible objection.
Northwestern’s civil rights office told Teplitsky’s group that all registered student organizations agree to a non-discrimination policy.
“There is a fundamental distinction between freedom of association and discriminatory exclusion from university-recognized activities,” he said.
“Spoon University is entitled to express political opinions and advocate for causes it supports,” he said. “But it cannot claim the privileges of university recognition while disregarding the nondiscrimination obligations it has agreed to follow.”
He called for further action.
“Northwestern has allowed a campus environment to develop in which excluding Jewish and Israeli students is increasingly treated as acceptable activism rather than potential discrimination,” Teplitsky said. “That needs to change.”
However, a national free speech expert says while there can be a reason to open a civil rights investigation, the school overstepped in freezing Spoon University’s status.
“Northwestern might have a basis to open a civil rights investigation if a preliminary inquiry suggests that the exclusion of Wildcats for Israel was based on ethnicity, religion, or national origin,” Robert Shibley told The Fix via email.
“Political disagreements by themselves, including about the Israeli-Palestinian issue, are protected by the First Amendment [and] do not violate civil rights laws,” Shibley, a counsel for the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression said. “If Northwestern determines that Wildcats for Israel was excluded because of disagreement over political issues alone, it must end the investigation.”
Commenting on Spoon University’s effective suspension, Shibley said “neither people nor groups should be punished before they are found guilty or responsible for some offense.”
Jewish student, peer founded Spoon University
Two Northwestern students founded Spoon University in 2012. At least one, Mackenzie Barth, grew up in a Jewish household. The other founder, Sarah Hartman, had a Jewish dad and Christian mother.
Barth declined to comment when reached by email.
Hartman, now the CEO of the Texas Tribune, did not respond to a request for comment.
The pair sold Spoon University, which has chapters across the country, to Scripps Network Interactive, who subsequently sold it to Her Campus Media.
The Fix emailed the national Spoon University as well as Her Campus Media and asked if the organization had an official position on Israel and if it supported or disagreed with the group’s decision. The Fix also left a voicemail for Her Campus Media, but none of these inquiries yielded a response.
The Fix also reached out to Wildcats for Israel via a listed email for student leader Mia Finestone and through its Instagram, but the group did not respond. Neither did Northwestern’s media relations team, including vice president Jon Yates, respond to emails and a voicemail in the last week. The campus Spoon University chapter also did not respond to email and Instagram inquiries.
A professor who said he is generally sympathetic to Palestine criticized Spoon University’s decision.
“By my senior year in high school, 1971-72, I came to the conclusion that I was not a Zionist and I was generally opposed to Israel’s occupation of parts of Palestine,” political science lecturer Jeff Rice, who is Jewish, wrote in the Daily Northwestern.
“Nothing since then has changed my mind, and I am even teaching a seminar on the difference between antisemitism and critiques of Israeli politics,” he wrote.
Yet, Rice wrote, ‘I deeply believe in free speech and academic freedom and deplore the shutting down of speakers, or cooks and bakers, for ethnic identity or political views on college campuses.”
He called for more discussion on the issue.
“I am not accusing Spoon or any organization on campus of advocating antisemitism, but we should all be careful when we isolate or ban groups for their thoughts.”
MORE: Professor faces backlash for book about antisemitism at MIT