FEATURED
LEGAL • LGBTQ

SCOTUS briefs: University hospital liable for teen’s gender care without dad’s consent

Share to:
More options
Email Reddit Telegram

The current Supreme Court of the United States; Fred Schilling/Supreme Court

Medical doctor says ruling in favor of University of California San Francisco would ‘be a clear breach of parental rights.’

The Supreme Court should rule that the University of California San Francisco does not have qualified immunity for a transgender surgery performed without the consent of a teenage boy’s father, parental rights groups say.

The nation’s highest court is currently considering amicus briefs in the case of Hudacko v. UC Regents, which concerns an alleged violation of a family custody order. 

As part of a divorce settlement with his wife, Ted Hudacko obtained a court order in 2020 that prohibited his then-teenage son from receiving any transgender surgeries without his approval. However, doctors at University of California San Francisco implanted a puberty blocker device inside Hudacko’s son, according to briefs submitted to the court. 

Officials argued that they have qualified immunity to make decisions and that the device implantation does not fit under the definition of a “surgery” as they understood it from the court order. The relevant custody order also said Hudacko’s son could continue receiving any other procedures from UCSF’s team. Hudacko’s ex-wife had full parental custody.

In 2023, the father sued the university, but the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals granted qualified immunity to the defendants, ruling that the procedure in question was not clearly defined as a “surgery,” as UCSF medical records refer to the implantation as a “procedure.”

A credentialed medical doctor who studies the consequences of transgender drugs and surgeries told The Fix the procedure qualifies as a surgery.

Doctors implant the capsule directly beneath the skin “containing Histrelin (a puberty blocker) [which] is a surgical procedure requiring consent of parents/guardians,” Dr. Quentin Van Meter said via emailed comments to The Fix. He is the former past president of the American College of Pediatricians and a practicing endocrinologist.

Van Meter says that ruling in favor of UCSF “would be a clear breach of parental rights that should be appealed to a higher court.”

He also told The Fix that the drugs injected into Hudacko’s son are experimental and can cause long term damage, as puberty is an important part of physical development.

Van Meter says these puberty blockers can lead to irreversible damage to bone health, suppress reproductive development, and halt essential brain maturation. 

“More telling,” Van Meter told The Fix, “is that once puberty blockers are started, 98% of the patients go on to opposite sex hormones with all of the known morbidities that accompany such interventions.”

Several amicus briefs concurred with Van Meter’s concerns about the effect a ruling in favor of the university could have on people in similar situations fighting to stop procedures on their minor children.

“Parental rights are not just the oldest and most fundamental right of citizens. They are clearly established in law,” Partners for Ethical Care’s amicus brief states. “The refusal by various states to recognize the rights of parents represents a perennial problem.”

America’s Frontline Doctors said in its own brief that “[p]rotecting one’s own children from harm is a well-established and constitutionally protected fundamental parental right.”

Qualified immunity, or the right of government officials to be protected from prosecution for their actions, is also a key part of this case. However, the Thomas More Society argues it should not apply here, as it is usually understood for protecting law enforcement and others who need to make snap judgements in dangerous situations.

“Qualified immunity is a tool to protect officials who must act in the moment,” the public interest legal group stated in its amicus. “It should not, however, protect officials who spend months deciding to keep a parent in the dark about his child’s impending gender transition procedure.”

“In this context, the application of qualified immunity can and should look different than the Court’s standard application in an excessive force case,”  the legal group stated.

It cited Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas in Hoggard v. Rhodes. 

“Why should university officers, who have time to make calculated choices about enacting or enforcing unconstitutional policies, receive the same protection as a police officer who makes a split-second decision to use force in a dangerous setting,” Justice Thomas asked.

UCSF says it had permission, qualified immunity shouldn’t be touched in this case

The College Fix contacted the University of California San Francisco several times for comment on the case and any additional context needed to understand its position. 

Public relations director Jess Berthold did not respond to an email and voicemail left in the past several weeks. An out-of-office email to public affairs director Kristen Bole directed The Fix to contact Berthold.

However, the university filed its own amicus brief on Wednesday, arguing the court order specifically allowed for “hormone therapy.”

It pointed out Hudacko also did not have established parental rights.

The brief also argues this is not the proper case to even address qualified immunity, as there are no circuit splits currently on this controversy.

Rather, there are too many questions left open by the state custody ruling as to the definition of surgery, to make this a candidate for reconsidering qualified immunity, UCSF attorneys argue.

Christine Underhill, Hudacko’s ex-wife, filed a brief letter saying she agrees with the university’s filing. 

MORE: Four states prohibit men from competing in women’s sports