EDITORS' CORNER
FREE SPEECH • OPINION/ANALYSIS

U. Michigan student claims conservatives’ ‘fighting words’ and lack of permit justify violence against them

Share to:
More options
Email Reddit Telegram

A rebuttal message written in the sand; kaesunza / Shutterstock.com

ANALYSIS: You can he attacked for asking if Islam is compatible with the West … and pointing out females can’t walk around Iran scantily clad?

Remember earlier this month at the University of Michigan when angry, septum-pierced Temulun Togochog attacked conservative activist Liz Benichou and threatened to kill her?

Well, women’s studies major Allana Smith — who’s also on a pre-law(!) track according to her LinkedIn — asks in The Michigan Daily that since Benichou and her colleagues allegedly used “fighting words,” what did you expect from Togochog?

“Yes, violence begets violence, but what is the natural ending to fighting words?” Smith queries. “Here’s a fun little proverb: There is always someone crazier than you.”

Apparently asking if Islam is “compatible with the West” and pointing out that scantily clad females would not be allowed to walk around freely in Iran constitute “fighting words.” That’d be news to constitutional scholars.

Also worth noting is what journalist Jesse Singal wrote recently: “I know ‘words are violence’ was sort of a culture war punchline, but it seems like a subset of people really have taken it to heart and believe actual physical violence, if necessary, is warranted to prevent someone […] from speaking.”

Allana Smith / LinkedIn

Another major point of contention for Smith is the fact that Benichou’s group Liberty Under Fire did not have a permit to set up their table at the campus Diag, something about which Togochog had asked prior to her violent behavior.

Smith believes that since Benichou et. al. aren’t “black or brown,” they thought they somehow were above needing a permit. (Tell that to the University of Mississippi students who got wall-to-wall mainstream media coverage for acting like typical drunk college students.)

She adds the university doesn’t appear to worry about permits if “you are here to bully or otherwise berate women and students of Color.”

(Benichou noted the inanity of this allegation by pointing out her group at U-M included a “black man, a black female, a Puerto Rican woman, a Mexican man,” and herself — a Jewish woman.)

There’s no indication Liberty Under Fire knew they needed a permit to set up their table; after campus safety officials were summoned to the scene, the group complied and began packing up to leave.

Smith continues:

The right-wing influencer believes that they are untouchable. It is by virtue of their identity as white people or men that they are owed grace and protection from all other bodies deemed inferior. They’re not always wrong; they are given grace, and they are given protection. That is, until someone decides that they have nothing to lose. 

White students and administrators are appalled at these reactive violences; the preceding conflict was no matter to them. They make us look bad. Words are dust; the student of Color must always endure. They should be prosecuted. They are not us.

Let me see if I have this straight: Benichou and company didn’t have a permit, and complied with law enforcement when informed.

Oh, but suddenly, permits and permission are important! Anti-Israel activists sure didn’t think so when they “occupied” various rooms and buildings over the last three years, berated fellow students (and school officials), and interrupted myriad events including graduations.

And let’s go a step further: How many colleges in the U.S. are so-called “sanctuary” campuses? U-M isn’t officially one, but notes it “remains steadfast in its commitment to providing a safe, inclusive environment for all, regardless of immigration status.”

U-M is like many universities — it doesn’t (or can’t) officially embrace the term “sanctuary” school, but certainly many students and student/faculty groups have advocated for such.

This is truly amazing. You can be in the country illegally and colleges will pretend not to notice. But no permit to discuss political issues at a public university? Get outta here!!

And what you did manage to say before packing up and leaving is subject to actions like Ms. Togochog’s if they perceive it as “fighting words.”

Keep in mind, Smith is on a pre-law track. 😳

MORE: Poll: 80% of Americans believe ‘words can be violence’