The College Fix

Whoever ‘approved this mockery … should be called upon to resign,’ music composer says

A doctoral student at the University of Nebraska recently orchestrated a drag performance appropriating the Catholic Mass for the final recital of his musical degree.

The performance imitated various parts of the Mass, including the Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus, and Agnus Dei. It was hosted by Our Saviour’s Lutheran Church of Lincoln, Nebraska.

Two Catholic and conservative advocates told The College Fix that this “mockery” of their faith reveals a double standard in singling out Christianity and highlights a significant lack of academic rigor in university programs.

Doctoral student Joseph Willette said in an Instagram video that the performance “truly feels like the culmination of [his] past couple of years studying music composition as well as gender, sexuality, and queer communities.”

“At the core of this work lies the juxtaposition of the holy and the profane, the sacred and the sinful,” he said.

The “sacred” is represented by the traditional Mass, while the “sinful” is shown in “the queer imagery and art forms,” Willette said.

A video of the performance was posted on YouTube, in which a drag artist can be seen performing near the front of the church while instrumentalists play on stage.

“Mass of Perpetual Indulgence for chamber orchestra, electronics, soprano solo, and drag performer was written to bridge the gap between queerness and spirituality, to sanctify queer people and celebrate our lives and communities,’’ the video description states.

“Amalgamating musical styles ranging from disco to opera, art song to EDM, this appropriation of the traditional Mass blurs the lines between the sacred and the profane,” it states.

Willette earned a doctorate of musical arts in composition at the Glenn Korff School of Music following the performance, according to the school website.

However, conservative critics condemned the performance as a bigoted mockery of the Catholic faith, arguing it should not be accepted by the school.

Peter Kwasniewski, a music composer and previously a Catholic college professor, told The Fix via email that the University of Nebraska academics “who approved this mockery or applauded it should be called upon to resign their positions.”

“What we’re seeing at work is a double standard, rooted in the old anti-Catholic bigotry that stains the history of the United States of America,” he said.

“We know that in any other context whatsoever, a public mockery of anyone’s religion — let’s say, Islam, or Judaism, or Buddhism — would have been vetoed by the faculty and, if not, would have created instant furor and demands for apologies and retributions,” he said.

He also told The Fix that anti-Catholic sentiments on campuses “likely stem from a broader anti-Christian and anti-Western bias driven by revisionist progressives in politics and academia.”

These progressives “perpetuate debunked myths or ‘black legends’ to secure cultural dominance—though they tend to misuse whatever influence they gain,” he said.

Similarly, Minding the Campus editor Jared Gould told The Fix that “the student’s choice to mock a Catholic Mass through a drag performance, rather than, say, reciting a surah of Muhammad in drag, raises questions about selective targeting.”

“Why is Christianity, and specifically the one, holy, Catholic, and apostolic Church, so often singled out for such provocations? This disparity suggests a lack of equal scrutiny across religions, undermining the intellectual honesty universities should champion,” he said.

Further, the Western university system only exists because of Christian churches and the early guilds that cultivated intellectual communities rooted in both faith and reason, Gould told The Fix.

He also said tax dollars should not be funding public institutions that reward such “cliché and intellectually shallow acts” that “add little to the arts or free speech.”

“Universities debase their own legacy by credentialing fools with the highest degrees for such trivial displays,” he said.

Finally, Gould said these courses need to be thoroughly reviewed for their clear lack of academic rigor.

“Universities that endorse such nonsense have abandoned their purpose, choosing cultural vandalism over wisdom and failing to uphold the standards of the civilization they claim to serve,” he said.

The Fix reached out to the University of Nebraska media relations office, the Glenn Korff School of Music, and Willette via email multiple times in the last week for more information on the performance. None responded.

MORE: Columbia investigates student for criticizing transgenderism on social media

IMAGE CAPTION AND CREDIT: ‘Mass of Perpetual Indulgence’ performance at Our Saviour’s Lutheran Church; M Joseph Willette, Composer/Youtube

Like The College Fix on Facebook / Follow us on Twitter