FEATURED
ACADEMIA • CURRICULUM

Scholars fear beauty and art being replaced by power and politics in humanities, study finds

Share to:
More options
Email Reddit Telegram

A statue of Mozart; Alessandro Cristiano/Shutterstock

Study examining 400,000-plus dissertations finds decline in language about art and beauty, increase in power-related words

The pursuit of beauty appears to be losing ground in American humanities scholarship, according to a recent study that examined more than 443,000 dissertations.

The report “Humanities in Crisis: A Study of 65 Years of American Dissertation Trends,” published in October, found that the use of language related to aesthetics, including words concerning beauty and art, declined while identity and power-related vocabulary rose in literature and language departments.

Two scholars who spoke with The College Fix said the findings, published by the American Academy of Sciences & Letters, raise questions about how the humanities have changed and whether an increasingly political approach to scholarship has come at the expense of traditional questions about artistic merit, beauty, and the human experience.

“This decline reflects the politicization of the humanities, especially during the past three decades,” Yale University Professor Carlos Eire told The College Fix.

For the report, researchers at Stanford University analyzed changes in academic language within the humanities by looking at 400,000-plus doctoral dissertations from 678 U.S. universities between 1960 and 2025. 

Their research aims to offer a better understanding of “the most pressing threats faced by humanities programs, as well as the probable causes of the current crisis, and to provide hard data on the material, intellectual, and cultural losses created by that crisis,” according to the study’s preface.

One of the findings related to beauty and aesthetics.

According to the report, words about beauty and art, such as “harmony, elegance, renaissance, essence, and delicacy,” have declined consistently across humanities disciplines since 1988. 

Meanwhile, power-related vocabulary — words related to “authority, control, and influence” — surged during the same period, particularly in literature and language programs. By the 1990s, power-related language had overtaken both aesthetics and evaluation vocabulary in those departments, according to the study.

Eire, chairman of the AASL humanities study, believes that beauty has become less prominent in academic discussions because it is more difficult to incorporate into political frameworks.

“Beauty is now considered far less important than ‘Truth’ and ‘Goodness’ because ‘Beauty’ is much harder to politicize,” he told The Fix in a recent interview.

Eire also connected the growing prominence of power and identity vocabulary to the influence of leftist political thought in academia.

“The ascendancy of power-related vocabulary reflects the ever-increasing hegemony of leftist fixations among academics,” he said, explaining that questions of power are central to Marxist thought. He added that the academic emphasis on race, class, and gender identity is largely an extension of this preoccupation with power.

A loss of something fundamental?

The shift is especially significant in literary scholarship, where questions about the artistic and aesthetic qualities of a work have traditionally been central to its study.

In an interview with The Fix, medieval scholar Rachel Fulton Brown said the diminished emphasis on beauty represents a loss of something fundamental to the study of literature and the arts.

Medieval scholars understood beauty through the senses and regarded poetry as a means of delighting and persuading its audience, the University of Chicago professor said. The arts of the Christian liturgy, in particular, were intended to lift the mind and soul toward contemplation of God.

Scripture provided the theological foundation for this understanding of beauty, Fulton Brown said, referencing Wisdom 13:5, which speaks of beauty pointing to the Creator. “For from the greatness and the beauty of created things their original author, by analogy, is seen,” the scripture verse states.

“What has been lost in modern literary scholarship is precisely this sense of delight and wonder at the beauty of the artistic work,” Fulton Brown told The Fix.

She said contemporary scholarship’s emphasis on power and identity also has obscured the ultimate source of those concepts. Modern literary criticism increasingly treats power as something inherently sinister, she said, rather than recognizing the significance of the Creator as the ultimate source of power and identity.

“In this context, power has become something inevitably diabolical; something to be resisted at all costs, including the destruction of the tradition of worship on which the arts depend,” Fulton Brown said.

The consequences extend beyond how scholars interpret individual works of art. Fulton Brown suggested that reducing artistic expression to questions of political power and personal identity can diminish appreciation for the very human capacity to create.

She pointed to the biblical account of Moses receiving instructions for the construction of the tabernacle. In Exodus 25:40, God instructs Moses to make everything according to the pattern shown to him on the mountain.

Medieval scholars understood artistic creation as a response to patterns established by God, Fulton Brown said. Art was therefore not simply an exercise of human power or a means of expressing individual identity, but an opportunity to participate in something greater.

Fewer students graduating with humanities degrees

Last year, the number of students graduating with degrees in the humanities dropped to the lowest in nearly four decades, Forbes reported in September, referencing data from the American Academy of Arts & Sciences.

“U.S. colleges and universities awarded 164,847 bachelor’s degrees in the humanities in 2025, the smallest number since 1991 …” according to the report. “That represents a 30.4% fall from 2012, the recent peak for humanities degrees.”

Whether the shift in focus has contributed to declining student interest, however, remains an open question.

Eire cautioned against attributing the decline to any single cause.

“The decline in student interest in the humanities is due to a complex set of causes,” he said. “The politicization of the humanities is but one of many such causes, but it is not as significant as pragmatic issues, especially the issues of employment and income after graduation.”

He also emphasized that the academy’s study identified changes in academic language, but it did not establish why.

“The AASL study does not investigate what caused the decline, it simply identifies the decline,” Eire said. “Much more research is needed to determine causality.”

Nevertheless, the findings offer a glimpse into the changing priorities of humanities scholarship.

For Fulton Brown, the problem is not simply that scholars are asking different questions about art, but that they may be losing sight of why human beings create it in the first place.

“The trap is in the label itself: the ‘humanities,’ as if art is only about our capacities as human beings and never about why we have these capacities…” she told The Fix. “Focusing solely on the arts as something by which human beings exercise power over each other and/or express their identities cuts us off from the wonder at being able to make art at all.”

MORE: Popular Harvard class is ‘brutal,’ requires students to read long books weekly