Protesters argue standardized tests are biased against minority, low-income students
About 100 University of California students rallied Tuesday to demand that the UC Board of Regents maintain test-free admissions, pushing back against faculty calls to reinstate the SAT and ACT amid declining math proficiency.
The UC Student Association organized the rally and held a press conference at UC San Francisco, arguing that “the exams shut out low-income students and students of color,” according to The New York Post.
Students wore shirts and held signs that read, “Public education should not be a luxury,” and “My story is bigger than a number,” according to the San Francisco Chronicle.
Also that day, UCSA President Candice Phan told the Regents during public comment at their meeting that the system needs to focus on “equity,” the NYP reported.
“So rather than blaming students, the UC needs to look itself in the mirror, assess the landscape and timeline which we are in, and decide how we are to move forward in a way that truly centers student experience, equity, and access,” she said.
UC Regents also heard from Brown University economics Professor John Friedman, who presented an opposing argument.
He said his research shows that low standardized test scores indicate a student will struggle in college, even if they have a strong high school GPA, The Daily Bruin reported.
“These disparities reflect underlying disparities and inequality in school quality and other environmental factors that affect students from different backgrounds,” Friedman said. “They are not biases in the test itself.”
Many UC faculty are siding with Friedman.
This year, over 3,000 UC faculty have signed a letter calling for the return of standardized testing in admissions after the system ditched the tests in 2020.
“Over the past five years, we have seen a widening divergence in mathematical preparation levels within the same classroom. This trend indicates that current admissions practices do not provide a sufficiently reliable check on mathematical readiness for STEM majors,” the letter reads.
Citing the UC San Diego Senate–Administration Workgroup on Admissions report, the letter adds that the number of incoming students with math skills below high school level has surged nearly thirtyfold.
Further, 70 percent of these students are performing below middle school level.
UC Davis math Professor Joel Hass told The California Post, “Standardized testing is the only objective method available in the admissions process that compares student preparedness across different schools.”
“It provides essential information to the admissions process,” he said.
MORE: Rowdy protest disrupts speech by ex-Border Patrol chief Greg Bovino at Rutgers University