UNCATEGORIZED

Washington State U. bans Greek life for first-semester freshmen, raising free speech concerns

Share to:
More options
Email Reddit Telegram

Fraternity members posing; Neal Cruz /CanvaPro

Ban infringes on freedom of association, free speech expert says

Washington State University recently announced that first-semester freshmen are prohibited from joining Greek life starting the spring semester of 2027. In response, a free speech group is raising First Amendment concerns. 

The ban on sorority and fraternity membership will give first-semester freshmen time to acclimate to college life, explore other opportunities around campus, and understand the responsibilities associated with Greek life, the school stated in an announcement on its new Student Belonging and Success Initiative.

“This shift provides students more time to be a Coug first, settle into college, focus on academics and make friends,” it stated. Other campus organizations are invited to adopt this approach as well, according to the announcement.

WSU’s initiative also aims to mitigate some of the dangers that can come with rushing. 

“The university will also implement stronger recognition and accountability standards for participating fraternities and sororities, including expectations around hazing prevention, alcohol and drug risk management, sexual misconduct prevention, advisor involvement, leadership training, transparency and cooperation with university interventions,” the announcement states. 

“The goal is to preserve the friendships, leadership opportunities, service and lifelong connections that make fraternity and sorority life meaningful,” it stated. 

But a free speech group is criticizing the school for limiting group assembly.

Noah Young, program counsel for the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, told The College Fix that because Washington State University is a public institution, it does not have the right to keep students from joining any organization simply because they are students. 

“Freedom of association is an essential part of the First Amendment, and this policy impermissibly restricts students’ core free expression rights,” Young said. 

“Students don’t lose their right to choose which communities to join simply because they’re on a college campus, and WSU has no authority to take that right from them at the door,” he said. 

Young also told The Fix that the limitation denies students two essential First Amendment rights: freedom of association and freedom of speech. The two rights are “closely intertwined,” he said. 

Young quoted a Supreme Court decision, which states, “the right to speak is often exercised most effectively by combining one’s voice with the voices of others.”

In addition to Young’s concerns that free speech and freedom of assembly are being denied for WSU students, he is also concerned by the fact that Greek life is the only type of organization limited for freshmen at WSU.

“It’s also worth noting that this restriction doesn’t apply to other student organizations. First-semester students can still join other social, political, religious, and philanthropic groups,” Young said. 

“Singling out Greek organizations in this way raises serious concerns about unequal treatment and whether the university is improperly discriminating against these organizations and the values or messages they represent,” he said. 

Come spring, Greek life’s limitations will be enforced while the university invites “existing organizations … to transition and participate in the new first-year community approach,” Young told The Fix.

In light of these concerns, FIRE has offered to help WSU revise its policy. 

“We’re happy to work with WSU administrators, free of charge, to identify ways to advance the university’s legitimate goals without infringing on students’ constitutional rights,” Young said. 

Helping students successfully transition into campus life and stay safe doesn’t “require a blanket prohibition on first-semester students joining fraternities and sororities,” he said.

The move comes amid ongoing problems in Greek life, including the 2019 death of Sam Martinez and multiple reported sexual assaults, The Daily Evergreen reported.

Martinez’s mother, Jolayne Houtz, supports the policy and first proposed the idea shortly after her son’s death. She is also suing the university, alleging it failed to protect him. 

However, students strongly opposed the policy, with more than 1,000 protesting the day after it was announced, saying administrators had not consulted them first.

WSU isn’t the first university to implement a policy of this kind.

The University of Maryland enforced a deferred recruitment policy, but dropped it after a university working group found no evidence that delaying recruitment meaningfully improves academic performance or student safety, The Daily Evergreen reported.