FEATURED
ANTISEMITISM • DIVERSITY

Antisemitism concerns raised after Hunter College cultural event canceled over Jewish group’s participation

Share to:
More options
Email Reddit Telegram

An Israeli flag; Steve Sanchez Photos/Shutterstock

‘Jewish affinity group should not have to defend its place in a multicultural event,’ Hunter College student says

Hunter College’s student government is facing scrutiny after it canceled a cultural event Monday when some participants reportedly backed out in protest of a campus Jewish group’s participation.

The New York college’s Undergraduate Student Government announced that the Cultural Arts Night was canceled in a post Saturday on Facebook, citing communication problems. 

However, several statements by student government leaders also implied that some participants were upset when they learned that Hillel, a campus Jewish organization, also was participating. 

The cultural event was supposed to include Hillel, Students for Justice in Palestine, and several other ethnic and cultural student groups, campus newspaper The Hunter Envoy reports.

A Hunter College student who spoke with The College Fix said antisemitism is an on-going problem on campus.

Once again, Jewish students are “being told their inclusion is a problem to be managed,” the student said via email Thursday. The student asked to remain anonymous due to fears of being targeted.

“Jewish students should not have to justify wearing a Star of David in class, and a Jewish affinity group should not have to defend its place in a multicultural event,” the student said, adding that Hillel offers support services to anyone on campus, “Jewish or not.”

On Wednesday, college President Nancy Cantor cautioned anyone against accusing the student government leaders of discrimination.

“It is very important first and foremost for our college community members to know that the event was not cancelled by USG in order to exclude Hillel, which was among the early co-sponsors of the event,” Cantor stated in a campus message.

“At the same time, we are deeply concerned by reports that some groups withdrew their co-sponsorship of the event because of Hillel’s announced participation,” she stated. 

Cantor said the college is investigating the situation to determine whether any discrimination or harassment occurred.

The Hunter student who spoke with The Fix expressed hope about the investigation, saying action is needed to “ensure this kind of exclusion does not happen again.”

“Jewish students are not going anywhere, and we will not be pushed off this campus,” the student told The Fix. 

Meanwhile, several outside Jewish and pro-Israel groups are calling for the student government to be investigated as well. 

“The grown-ups need to step in when the kids are throwing a tantrum,” attorney Gerard Filitti with The Lawfare Project and #EndJewHatred stated in a news release Thursday, shared with The Fix.

Filitti said Hunter is a public institution that receives tax dollars, meaning both the college and its student government are “bound by the same non-discrimination rules.”

“Hunter’s response so far is not an accountability commitment,” Filitti stated. “We want an independent Title VI investigator brought in, and if the student government is found to have acted improperly, Hunter should suspend and replace it.”

Filitti’s The Lawfare Project also is in the middle of a lawsuit with Hunter College, filed in 2024, alleging the institution failed “to take meaningful action to address the rampant antisemitism on campus.”

On Thursday, his group, Israel on Campus Coalition, Students Supporting Israel, and the Israeli-American Council held a rally at the New York college to demand an independent investigation of the event cancellation.

Concerns about the reasons for the cancellation began with the student government’s initial statement over the weekend.

“Going forward, every club and every member of USG will know who is involved in an event before it is planned or approved,” the student government wrote Saturday on Facebook.

The event “doesn’t align with our values or the values of the students who we represent,” it stated. 

On Sunday, the student government issued another statement explaining that the event was “cancelled due to safety concerns” regarding “conflicting views of participating organizations.” 

“We recognize that our previous statements may have led to confusion and misinterpretations regarding the reasons for cancellation,” it stated, adding that it welcomes “all students” to participate in events.

But a comment that student government Vice President Ahmad Waraich made to the campus newspaper on Monday suggested the Students for Justice in Palestine chapter pushed for the event’s cancellation.

Waraich told The Envoy that a “collab with SJP and Hillel in this political climate” was a mistake, and the student government’s statement was “purposefully vague.”

Later, he told the student newspaper, “I have to retract my statement.”

Hunter Hillel had “no role in the student government’s decision to cancel,” its executive director told The Envoy.

“Antisemitism has no place at Hunter College. The antisemitic response to the cancellation notice has been egregious and inappropriate,” Hillel Executive Director Merav Fine Braun said.

Neither the campus media relations office nor the student government responded to The College Fix’s emails Thursday asking if the event would be rescheduled and if they had communicated with the campus Hillel or Students for Justice in Palestine groups since the cancellation announcement. 

MORE: ‘Deeply troubling’: Northwestern antisemitism group criticizes food fest’s exclusion of Israeli group